The Donald Trump era has been vastly destructive for American politics. This isn’t exactly a novel thought, but the degree to which trust in institutions has been eroded will likely take generations to repair. This anti-establishment push did not come from Trump; general resentment toward the status quo supercharged his 2016 election and played a major part in his 2024 re-election, albeit to a lesser degree. Trump has harnessed this sentiment effectively for the better part of the last decade, but that illusion is finally crumbling and with it, the electorate’s support for a Republican Party that has coalesced around him.
Saying Trump’s second term has been an unmitigated disaster may actually sell his administration’s calamitous track record short. Trump’s policies are widely unpopular and have only gotten worse over time. His approval rating is now down to 36%, the lowest for Trump at any point in both terms and the lowest for any president after two years since 1946. Given this political climate, and the fact that Trump approached the midterms by telling Americans to “pretend I’m on the ballot,” it’s no surprise that the Republicans fared badly in the midterm elections.
Still, even to the most optimistic voices within the Democratic Party, the magnitude of the electorate’s leftward shift came as a shock. Democratic candidates won races that were not even considered competitive, leading to a 56-seat total in the Senate and a projected 259 seats in the House of Representatives, which would be the largest House majority in over three decades. Trump is deeply unpopular, no doubt, but there is more going on here and this election cycle tells us a lot about the American electorate and what future elections could look like.
Firstly, it’s worth mentioning that many of these wounds were self-inflicted. Republicans, who campaigned heavily on affordability and the economy to great effect in 2024, seemed to want to talk about literally anything else this time around. While Democratic candidates utilized populist messaging around rising costs and the War in Iran, Republicans mostly hit back with fear-mongering about transgender people, communism and the threat of “sharia law.”
In some ways, Republicans backed themselves into a corner regarding affordability. Any attempt to address rising prices, such as when incumbent Mississippi GOP Senate candidate Cindy Hyde-Smith told voters to “pick another protein” in response to rising beef costs, backfired. Hyde-Smith’s opponent, Democrat Scott Colom, responded with an ad with the message: “Pick another protein? I’d rather pick another senator instead.” This worked; in a shocking upset, Colom won and will be the first Democratic senator from Mississippi since 1982 and the first Black senator elected in the state since the Reconstruction Era.
Colom wasn’t the only Democrat to play in deep-red territory and succeed. In Kansas, Methodist Minister Adam Hamilton became the first Democratic senator-elect for the state since 1932. In South Carolina, Dr. Annie Andrews capitalized on a uniquely terrible GOP candidate in Darlene Graham. In Alaska, Iowa, Maine, North Carolina and Ohio, Democrats secured Senate wins and flipped Republican-held seats. Internet celebrity Dr. Abdul El-Sayed won his election in Michigan, becoming the first Muslim senator-elect in American history. Perhaps most remarkably, in the most expensive Senate race of all time, Democrat James Talarico defeated Ken Paxton in Texas.
This effect stretched down-ballot; six governorships were flipped, including Texas, Ohio and Georgia. House races that were anticipated to be safely Republican flipped too. Locally, Colorado’s 5th District, long considered a Republican stronghold, elected Democrat Jessica Killin. With more than 40 flips in the House, Democrats will enter 2027 with a commanding majority in both chambers. What they do with that power matters.
There has been a relatively strong post-election back-and-forth between the moderate and progressive wings of the Democratic Party over which ideology led to this electoral success, but both are missing the point. Progressives won close races in Maine, Michigan and down-ballot across the country. Similarly, moderate candidates such as Colom in Mississippi and Hamilton in Kansas successfully flipped their seats. So what led to this unprecedented success?
In short, the Democrats have finally learned how to utilize populist messaging. For the better part of the last decade, Democrats have been trying to contest politics under the preconception that they’re still in the pre-Trump era, but that hasn’t worked. Divisive as he is, Trump tapped into a tangible disillusionment with the status quo among the American electorate. This positioned the Republican/Democrat divide as outside voices versus the establishment. Whether or not this truly reflected party composition, the perception is all that matters and 2026 has flipped that on its head.
Successful candidates in 2026 tapped into real frustrations with the economy, largely opposed the Iran war and the continued support for Israel and promised to rid the government of corruption across the board, all broadly popular policies with young voters in particular. Candidate selection also mattered: Hamilton was a minister, El-Sayed a doctor, Troy Jackson in Maine was a former logger before he joined his state’s senate and he will be the only Senator without a college degree. This incoming Democratic coalition will include elected officials from a wide variety of backgrounds. This election wasn’t just a rebuke of the administration; voters were energized by intriguing candidates who felt authentic in a way the Democratic Party hasn’t portrayed itself in the past.
But this is where the Democrats are already struggling. This enthusiasm has been halted by the realization that the minority leaders in both chambers, who are both likely to be elected majority leaders, are among the most unpopular politicians in the country. Chuck Schumer, Senate Minority Leader, has an approval rating of just 13% among voters and House leader Hakeem Jeffries is marginally higher at 28%. Their unpopularity stems from the fact that both of their ideologies and attitudes are those of the Democratic Party establishment, which voters are not particularly fond of.
Schumer does have a challenger: Chris Van Hollen from Maryland, who is seen as more progressive than the current minority leader. Van Hollen appears to have real, tangible momentum, but whether he can take enough votes from Schumer to win the position seems doubtful. Jeffries, on the other hand, appears to be running unopposed for speaker of the house.
It raises a real question: if the American people on both sides of the aisle seem generally against Jeffries and Schumer’s leadership, what does it say about our democratic structure that there doesn’t appear to be a clear way to change that?

